Geds APA ( of sorts)

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Alasdair on April 13, 2009 at 6:13pm

Nice one, Ged. I really enjoyed your beer.

Nice aroma of citrus and cystal malt, with a hint of stonefruit (from the yeast?). Great appearance - nice head, lovely colour and clarity.

The hop flavour dominates initially, then malt sweetness, and a lingering, grassy, teeth-scraping bitterness - I think this was the sharpness that Stu referred to. I found the beer more balanced once it warmed up - the caramel came out a bit more and the bitterness was more rounded.

Well brewed and very tasty, but I'd prefer a bit more hop flavour and aroma, a smoother bitterness, and a bit less crystal malt. Not necessarily flaws in your beer, but more of a reflection of how I like my pale ales (my APA doesn't have any crystal malt in it).

Cheers

Permalink Reply by Dale Cooper on April 13, 2009 at 8:58pm

I really like this. I have a beer fermenting right now that I hope turns out anywhere near this good. Looks great tastes awesome. Loved it. I love hoppy beers and struggle to make my own so... RESPECT!!
Yummy orange marmalade, mmm mmm.

Permalink Reply by Ged on April 13, 2009 at 9:44pm

Thx heaps for the feeback guys..I got to admit, this is the best beer I've done so far out of around 5 AG's....Lady luck has a lot to answer for so think I'll start to get a bit more scientific now and follow the recipes until I understand whats what

Permalink Reply by Stu McKinlay on April 13, 2009 at 9:48pm

Don't get too scientific... I was a golfer, back in the day, and anyone who got too scientific ended up "chopping it". Keep it simple when planning, be careful and thoughtful on brew day, and enjoy great beer.

Permalink Reply by jt on April 13, 2009 at 9:54pm

Keep it simple when planning, be careful and thoughtful on brew day

... and take some notes ?
It'll help next time round

Permalink Reply by Stu McKinlay on April 13, 2009 at 9:57pm

or post them on here and go back to them later...

Permalink Reply by denimglen on April 14, 2009 at 7:34pm

Pours two finger loose head that turns extremely rocky, cloudy and sticky, can tell the lace on this will be good. Dark gold in colour with slight haze.

Citrus, a touch of grapefruit and pine needles. A strong sweet creamy caramel aroma comes through subtly, doesn't make sense eh? Some peach/apricot-like fruit as well.

Caramel comes through nicely in flavour and is supported well by a lingering fruity bitterness. Some orange hop flavour there too. Some crunchy, crust, biscuit, maltiness as well.

Medium body, slightly over medium carbonation, it is a touch minerally in bitterness but not unpleasant but would hold me back from drinking copious amounts...actually it probably wouldn't.

Very nice beer, I'd be tempted to cut back the crystal or up the flavour hops, or maybe both. Maybe drop 200g crystal and swap out with some amber/biscuit/victory type malt to keep the maltiness there but it may accentuate the hops a bit more. Dry hopping would also help. But it's not far off the mark, no need to make it an IPA. I still can't get over the sticky bitch of a head she's got, especially for a simple malt bill, it's like a freakin' liquid candy floss sponge or something haha.

Permalink Reply by Doublehoppy on April 23, 2009 at 10:24pm

Poured this when it was cool, but not cold. Pours very clear, very little yeast sediment in the bottle. Did you bottle this from a keg or was it primed in the bottle?

This is very tasty!. Quite nutty, I suspect you've used Maris Otter pale?? Has a lovely aroma and initial sweetness with a lingering bitterness.

Like some of the previous posters I'd suggest you consider cutting back on the crystal to let the hops come through. But hey.. it's a beauty

I punched your recipe into beersmith so I could estimate the IBU's. Comes out at 47 BTW.

I could drink a lot of this...

Permalink Reply by Ged on April 24, 2009 at 8:24am

Hi mate...Pale malt was from Gladfields - just outside Christchurch ( via wigrams brewery). It was bottled from the fermenter and a couple of sugar drops stuck into each bottle..The remaing 10 litres made the keg and was soon finished...I'm playing around with your suggestions to get more hop aroma and flavour in there. Glad you enjoyed it...Ged

• ‹ Previous
• 1
• 2
• Next ›
• Page