NZ Homebrew Reviews

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by denimglen on May 11, 2011 at 7:12am

"The goal of the channel is to have a panel of average guys, taste and rate beers, and to give honest and uncomplicated review on it get free beer"

 

Haha ;-)

 

Good idea guys, will keep an eye on it.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Paul Wicksteed - another1 on May 11, 2011 at 9:14am

Damn my evil plan for free beer has been foiled :)

 

Normally I do a beer swap with the brewer, I have been trying to organize a swap with a guy in New Mexico, but the freight costs are $120 each way, thats far to much to pay for a beer. Do you have any beers you want to send in?

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Greig McGill on May 11, 2011 at 8:17am

Hey Paul. I gave probably more than my share of feedback on the first one, but since I'm an annoying and opinionated b'stard, I shall offer some more! ;)

 

I've watched them all so far, and I have a few more suggestions:

 

• It could be useful to have someone on the panel with a bit more knowledge and experience to temper the interesting "first time" beer tasting vibe. Don't get me wrong, I like the angle of having tasters who, while not new to beer, are new to *thinking about* what they are drinking, but I think it could be good to have someone there who can perhaps better explain the goal of a given style or beer so it can be more critically evaluated. Your show, your angle, your choice, but just a suggestion.
• The summary titles can sometimes flash past a bit too quickly, and be poorly proofed. The one that always bugs me is when people use "palette" (a selection of available colours) instead of "palate" (flavour profile and appreciation thereof). Don't worry, it's not just you, people do it all the time and my inner spelling nerd cries out in pain. ;)
• The intro sequence is a bit too long. After seeing it once, I always just want to skip it which isn't always easy to do accurately when the media is still loading.

 

That said, I'm totally going to send you a beer for review sometime soon so you can tear it apart and have your revenge. ;) I'll make it something "The Pom" will enjoy I think...

 

Cheers,

 

Greig.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Paul Wicksteed - another1 on May 11, 2011 at 9:06am

Thanks for the suggestions. We have an opening coming up for a reviewer, due to "the CONTRACTORS" contract expiring, and since we do the filming at work, he wont be around. I have a couple of people in mind, but if you know somebody in the wellington region let me know.

 

Palette and Palate, I will adjust it for the next video. I try and tie the titles to the audio, but sometimes the editing is a bit quick, so I will make sure during filming we get a bit of pause before cutting to the next segment, to extend the title time. 

One of the biggest issues we have is sound, i have been looking for a 4 channel amp w/ 3 wireless lavaliers, but the price range is around $4000, so have been tryin to come up with a cheaper solution.

 

My wife is the videographer / editor, and she is doing this as an ongoing project for the New York Video School, where each episode is critiqued by her peers. She has her own youtube channel as well, that is going really well, last month she got the highest video views in a week for a NZ partner channel. So hopefully the same momentum can happen with this channel.

 

Cheers Greig, I appreciate your feedback and I look forward to reviewing your beer. I will send you my version of "Theakstons, Old Peculier" for you to review, what address can I send it to, or when are you next in wellington and we can meet for a beer.

 

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Greig McGill on May 12, 2011 at 10:28am

Cheers Paul. I'll be in Welly for Beervana. Probably arriving early on Tuesday so as to quietly build up to the main event! ;) If you want to send it to me before then, I'm at 23 Saxbys Road, Deanwell, Hamilton 3206.

 

• ▶ Reply